Sight Privilege and You

To my future instructors, please remain in communication with your visually impaired student. It is important to discuss deadlines and things on the syllabus with the student in discussion. Although they have assistance gathering resources and converting documents into an accessible format these things do take time. The office for Students with Disabilities is made up of a staff of students. Sometimes a conversion of a single document can take up to 3 days if it isn’t a clear copy. These time conflicts can throw off the timing of an assignment and may cause the student to hand in late submissions. Also as previously mentioned, the staff members of the SDS office are students as well. We are all on the same schedule and may have major assignments or exams that are due at the same time. Please be aware that may be a hindrance to the student and may not allow them to complete certain tasks in a timely manner.

In closing, I would also like to emphasize that there is a fine line between sympathy and empathy. Instructors, please remember to empathize for the student but never to sympathize for them except for in certain circumstances. Sympathizing for the student may not allow them to get the full experience of the course. It is important that you push the impaired student to their full potential in order to ensure the best result. This can also help with building morale for this student and encourage them to take more courses.

If an instructor does sympathize for the student and this student becomes aware they may use it to their advantage. You don’t want to be fooled into giving someone a good grade because you felt sorry for them instead of them earning it.

 by Anthony Butler

Pages: 1 2
Leave a comment

5 Comments

  1. Eva Romulus

     /  April 23, 2014

    Two thumbs up for the author of this blog post! Very useful information. Most students do not realize that details like these can make a big difference not only to people with visual disabilities, but also to people with other types of disabilities. Although I want to believe we all try to be supportive and considerate, when the time comes many people don’t know how to help. We need to remember that not all of us have the same abilities, and it’s about time we start respecting and supporting our classmates to overcome some of these barriers.

    Like

    Reply
  2. Mylanie

     /  April 24, 2014

    I really enjoyed reading this post. I found a lot of this information really interesting and it made me think a lot about the unique difficulties that universities place on students with disabilities. For instance, where I studied for my undergrad almost all the professors had a clause written into their syllabus that said if a student had a disability they had to notify the prof about it within the first two weeks of class in order to be accommodated. Got diagnosed with something mid semester? Too bad.

    Turns out, that this was actually out of line with the policies created by the university’s disability services. But due to several factors, it wasn’t being reported, and because it wasn’t being reported, nothing was being done about it.

    This example plus the experiences you outlined above, expose just some of the ways in which the university setting is an unfriendly space for students with disabilities.

    Like

    Reply
  3. Nora Armenta

     /  April 26, 2014

    I believe that this article brings light to things that people with regular eyesight do not have to face. I couldn’t imagine getting around and especially going to new school where everything is a new experience for everyone. Its helpful to identify the difference between empathy and sympathy regarding this issue. It’s practical to help students with their specific needs but also not to micromanage their work. I’ve see it in my experience where a person who meant well was overly sympathetic and it did not turn out well. I think that they miss a blind spot where if you do work for them or let them get an easier grade just based on their disability, you’re really just hurting them in the long run and limiting the students potential.

    Like

    Reply
  4. juan843

     /  May 1, 2014

    I really appreciated this post and the author, for sharing his experiences and challenges, as a student with a visual impairment, at the New School. Anthony’s experiences at the New School, highlights some of the progress or improvements, the school is yet to make for students with disabilities. I hope the school takes note of the challenges Anthony’s faced, and hires more staff members for the office for Students with Disabilities, who will carry exclusive responsibilities, to assist the students. The school’s resources should be equally distributed for the needs and assistance of students with or without disabilities.

    I would also like to further comment, that I appreciate the author’s advice given to other students, on how to interact with students with disabilities. Often times, I find myself not knowing how to act when attempting to assist a student a see with an impairment or disability. This brings me to the point of being able to distinguish between sympathizing and empathizing with a student with a disability. I’ve encountered people with disabilities who don’t like being helped, for they feel as if they’re being treated as if they are helpless and therefore are apprehensive when one offers to assist them. And that is totally understandable. As Anthony points out in his post, treat that individual with respect, empathize, but not sympathize, to the extent that you treat that individual, as someone who cant fend for herself/himself, and are therefore, at the mercy of others. Treat the person as someone who is fully capable, and challenge him, and he/she will respond. At the same time, I do feel the need to assist them, if I find them to be having trouble performing any type of activity they’re attempting to carry out. Hence, I’ve found myself in situations in which I’ve needed assistance, yet however, the people surrounding me, act indifferent to my needs and carry on with their activities. I can only imagine the frustration one might feel when you truly need help and yet no one bothers to stop and assist you.

    Moreover, for the author, Anthony, you do not need to prove to anyone your equal; you are more than equal. You wake up every morning knowing the daily challenges you’ll face, but you decide to take those challenges head on and overcome them. Many other people in life, with or without disabilities, choose to let their circumstances in life define them. They don’t instead; choose to define the extent to which that circumstance will define their life.

    Like

    Reply
  1. Can’t You See I’m the Cutest Girl in the Room? | The New School Free Press

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: